5 Leadership Styles in Nursing
Table of Content
In these meetings, each instructor has an opportunity to discuss concerns, ask questions, and offer opinions about how to help students and improve the nursing department. When important decisions need to be made, Ms. Wilson brings facts about the situation to the attention of the instructors and asks for input. Once she has had a chance to review suggestions and think about options, Ms. Wilson decides how to proceed.
Integrity is vital for making the right decisions for patients and team members. Leaders with integrity often show compassion and don’t put profits over people. They respect you as an individual and as an essential member of the team. Other influencing factors include tasks and responsibilities of leaders (Hakanson et al., 2014; Kristiansen et al., 2016) and available budget and time. Although they emphasize that leadership depends on situations and people, Nielsen and Cleal relate a stable organization positively to leadership. Setting high standards can help managers identify top performers and weed out those with low productivity, driving improved business results.
Leadership styles in nursing
The idea of finding and developing leadership styles in nursing may leave you feeling as if you are in uncharted waters. One thing that is always certain about nursing is that it’s a learning process. The following are some examples of TEDx talks, YouTube videos, podcasts, and books to help you as you begin to develop your leadership skills and style. When employees feel the only incentive to stay with an employer is the potential for earning a reward, they may become more inclined to pursue other opportunities, resulting in higher employee turnover rates. In transactional leadership environments, employees know what is expected of them. Therefore, nurse leaders often cast blame on team members who fail to meet goals.
Learn more about how an MSN degree can help you improve your leadership skills and advance your medical knowledge by exploring AdventHealth University Online’s healthcare degree programs. Our study describes that passive-avoidant leadership styles are excessively present in contrast to transformational leadership styles in nursing homes. Given the importance of leadership to face current and future challenges, these findings indicate an urgent need to invest in leadership development in nursing homes. To promote transformational leadership, future research should focus on interventions for leadership development. Prior to this, an instrument to measure leadership in the specific context of nursing homes should be developed.
Related articles
While informal nurse leaders cannot hire and fire employees, they’re often regarded as the champions and troubleshooters of the unit. Association between nursing home staff turnover and infection control citations. The relationship of education level to the job tenure of nursing home administrators and directors of nursing. •Today in Nursing Leadership offers meaningful discussions about nurse leadership and how to achieve your highest potential. No matter how great your team is, if you work with them long enough, you will see conflicts.
Available information and information flowForbes-Thompson et al. 2007), Hakanson et al. 2014), Jeon et al. and Vesterinen et al. Available budget and timeAli and Terry , Cummings et al. , Hakanson et al. , Nielsen et al. and Rokstad et al. Tasks and responsibilitiesHakanson et al. , Jeon et al. , Kristiansen et al. and Nielsen et al. Given that larger nursing homes have more residents for whom the negative outcomes could occur, the negative binomial regression used the number of residents at risk for each measure as the exposure level for that measure. The coefficients are reported in incident-rate ratio form, which is similar to odds ratios, that is, estimates greater than one represent a positive association between the explanatory variable and the outcome. The assessment of leadership style in this study came from primary data collected from approximately 4,000 NHAs and DONs.
Different Management Styles in Nursing
While they promote creativity and ingenuity, they typically don’t provide guidance or direction. You can often see this type of leadership style among new or inexperienced nurse leaders. A laissez-faire leadership style is a facilitative one in which a leader makes few decisions.
Of the many leadership styles, transformational leadership has been lauded as the most effective for nurse leaders, including those with a DNP. A study by the Institute of Medicine’s Committee on the Work Environment for Nurses and Patient Safety found transformational leadership promotes the pursuit of jointly held goals in healthcare. In every nursing home, a moment was scheduled in which staff completed a survey, rating leadership styles of their direct supervisor. The first level involved the leadership of head nurses, who plan, coordinate, monitor, control and adjust the activities on their ward in order to ensure that staff can deliver individualized care in optimal conditions . The second level involved the leadership of directors of nursing , who are continuously balancing between clinical leadership and managerial targets. DoN have a complex role in budgets and finances, staff recruitment, handling staff conflicts, monitoring of care quality and representation to other organizations .
For instance, in bureaucratic leadership environments, everything must go through a chain of command which means work may not be performed on time. This type of leadership does not encourage professional or personal growth or foster collaboration and interprofessional team building. Many employees who work under bureaucratic nurse leaders seem to feel that their ability to exercise innovation, free-thinking, and creativity is stifled. Careful observation of the leadership styles of nurse leaders in an organization or community demonstrates that leadership styles are as diverse as the leaders who employ them. An astute nurse leader can observe the style of leaders in healthcare, as well as in other professions, and emulate their successes, while learning from their failures.
Moreover, the current tendency toward flat organizations, decentralization and self-direction transforms leadership into a more collective undertaking that transcends hierarchy and encompasses behavior, context and people. Tendencies toward networks of collaborating organizations require new leadership competencies that transcend organizational boundaries and interests. Therefore, a stronger focus on leadership behaviors in relationship to specific contexts instead of the application of leadership styles could provide more insight into what is needed when and what works. A validated Dutch version of the Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire 5X (MLQ-5X) form was used to measure leadership styles and outcomes of head nurses and DoN . The MLQ-5X comprises 45 items divided into nine subscales to capture a broad range of leadership behaviors. Items are scored using a five-point Likert scale with responses that range from “never” to “frequently, if not always” .
When both the NHA and the DON have a consensus manager leadership style, six of the seven quality indicator coefficients are significant, with all the coefficients showing an association with better quality. Bivariate analysis revealed that several of the independent variables were significantly correlated but that multicolinearity was not a problem, as all the variance inflation factor values were less than 2.0. Analysis of variance was used to examine the relationship between caregiver turnover and leadership type. We used a general linear model to examine the association between leadership style and caregiver turnover. General linear models analyze responses for continuous dependent variables as a function of their categorical or continuous independent variables.
To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study that quantitatively investigates and maps leadership styles and leadership outcomes of head nurses and directors of nursing in nursing homes. Compared with the European Reference Scores , head nurses and DoN score significantly lower . In addition, results showed that a consensus leadership style, that involves employees and encourages team decision making, was used by only 30% of DoN . Given the potential influences on care quality and patient safety, our results, showing low scores on transformational leadership styles and high scores on passive-avoidant leadership styles, are alarming.
Although the servant nurse leader has the authority to make decisions and exercises that authority, these leaders value the thoughts and ideas of their team members and, therefore, involve team members as much as possible. To gain success of the organizations, nurse managers often opt this type of leadership style in health care. This leader looks after for those who serve the patients and work hard to gain positive outcomes, i.e., the staff members. They pay special attention to their needs and ask the employees if they want any kind of help.
While a certain leadership style in nursing, such as autocratic leadership, may work well for one nurse manager, it may not work for another. Furthermore, employee well-being and satisfaction were stated as potential influencers of leadership. Finally, Havig and Hollister found that independent workgroups of caregivers, which had their own meetings, reports and administrator, could have a possible influence on nursing home quality. Their analysis revealed that workgroups were fostered by three mediators, namely, psychological ownership, perceived insider status and shared mental models.
Transactional Leadership in Nursing
To reward Ms. Winters’ dedication to the job, Nurse Michelle recommended a raise for Ms. Winters. This is an example of using a reward system in transactional leadership in nursing. If you are comfortable delegating responsibility and allowing others to grow and learn, this leadership style may be something you can accomplish.
They were derived from higher executive levels of leadership, limiting their suitability for use in nursing homes . Therefore, the comparison of scores between a group of executives (i.e. the ERS) and head nurses in nursing homes should be interpreted with caution. European Reference Scores for leadership in health care settings could support a more accurate comparison. Second, compared with the sample size for raters of head nurses, the small sample size for raters of DoN may limit the generalizability of the results. However, this likely reflects the organizational proportions of functions in nursing home staff.
Comments
Post a Comment